When comparing peak efficiency levels it seems that there is little difference between flat plate and evacuated tubes. In fact, the efficiency of flat plate may actually be higher, only when it is during minimal heat loss conditions. But in long terms use, generally a year, evacuated tube collectors have a clear advantage. The key points are:
1. Owing to the cylindrical shape of the evacuated tubes, they are able to passively track the sun throughout the day. Flat plate collectors can only provide peak energy output at mid-day when the sun is perpendicular to the collector's surface. To know more about IAM and its performance click here.
2. Air is evacuated in the solar tube to form a vacuum condition. This greatly reduces the conductive and convective heat loss from the inner of the tube. Then wind and cold temperatures have less effect on the efficiency of the evacuated tube collector.
3. Sunflower solar collectors can operate in subzero temperatures without the system sustaining damage. Flat plate systems often require expensive and complicated "antifreeze" systems to be installed with.
4. Evacuated tubes are strong, long-lasting. And if one were broken, it is inexpensive and easy to replace. However, if a flat plate collector panel is damaged the whole panel must be replaced.
5. Owing to the high-efficient absorption of solar radiation even during couldy weathers, combined with excellent insulative properties of the solar tube, solar tube collectors can warm the water all year round (backup from gas and electricity is still required).
6. With the several advantages of evacuated tube collector over flat plate collectors, a smaller collector can be used to perform the same heating. For example, a standard family of 4-5 people would usually require a 250-300L water storage tank. According to your location, only 30 evacuated tubes would be enough to meet all summer hot water needs and a large percentage in other seasons.
7. Flat plate solar collectors can produce similar heat output to evacuated tube collectors only during hot and sunny conditions. Generally over an entire year, evacuated tube collector heat output per net m2 of absorber area, is between 25% to 40% greater than that of a flat plate collector.